Erica was seen frequently squabbling with her twin sister, Kayla. She sometimes can be pretty defiant.
Like Tori, Erica was also seen being sent to the naughty step two times. On Jo's DVD footage Erica was seen refusing to close the refrigerator when her mom told her to. Erica's reason for refusing was that she didn't open the refrigerator (Tori did), but she went to the step anyway.
The second time was for refusing to finish her dinner (last three bites). With Jo's help dad gave Erica a warning, even though he wanted to put her in timeout right away and mom did the rest of the technique.
She was 6 years old when she appeared on Supernanny and is now 17 in 2018.
During reinforcement, after a warning, Erica covered her face (probably because she was embarrassed) and as soon as she got to the step, her emotions escalated to where she was sobbing and having a meltdown. She didn't want to show her face. Jo found that behavior "babyish" as Erica melts down and refused to sit up and look at her mom Cathy when she was talking to her on the step.
- "I hate the Naughty Step." (When she was interviewed)
- "I think we will have a really happy family soon." (When she was interviewed)
- "Get off of me." (2x)
- "I wasn't the one who opened it, Tori did."
- "Mom!" (5x)
- "Because I didn't open it."
- "I already ate!" (3x)
- "I ALREADY ATE ON MY PLATE!"
- "But I don't want to!"