Brody Allan Phelps (born September 25, 2004) is the middle child of Jimmy and Amy, younger brother of Jacob and older brother of Aiden.

He always got upset when he didn't get his own way and he was also very stubborn. He got sent to time out 3 times in the episode, so he got the most timeouts of the 3 boys. He only ate the chocolate with his Lunchables during observation, because Amy said that his throat was bothering him, and chocolate helps his throat.

He was 5 years old at the time and is 14 in 2017.